Skip to main content
Home
  • Newsletter
  • Cart
  • Languages
    • العربية
    • Deutsch
    • English
  • Profile
    • Login
    • Sign up
  • Log in / Register
  • Language
    • العربية
    • Deutsch
    • English
  • Home
  • Channels
    • Magazine
    • Photoaward
    • Libya Chronicles
    • zenithTalk
    • Lebanon Chronicles
    The Rise of Aydarous Zubaydi in Yemen
    The Rise of Aydarous Zubaydi in Yemen

    The Southern Comeback in Yemen

    Health and Water Management in Egypt and Sudan
    Health and Water Management in Egypt and Sudan

    Death on the Nile

    Migration out of Tunisia
    Migration out of Tunisia

    Harqa or the Boats of Death

    Protests in Balochistan and Kurdistan regions in Iran
    Protests in Balochistan and Kurdistan regions in Iran

    A New Day for Sunnis in Iran

    Iran Protests and the Crackdown in Balochistan
    Iran Protests and the Crackdown in Balochistan

    The Story of Zahedan’s Shaykh al-Islam

    Twitter, Facebook and censorship in Egypt
    Propaganda and messaging apps in Libya, Egypt and Ethiopia

    Messages in a Bottle

    Explore Channel
    fotopreis2017header2
    zenith Photo Award 2017

    Islam in Europe

    fotopreis2014header.
    zenith Photo Award 2014

    Islam in Germany (2014)

    fotopreis2013header4
    zenith Photo Award 2013

    Muslims in Germany (2013)

    fotopreis2011header2
    zenith Photo Award 2011

    Islam in Germany (2011)

    Explore Channel
    Detention Centers in Libya
    Detention Centers in Libya

    Waiting between cage and gun

    Interview with Raphael Luzon on the fate of Libyan Jews
    Interview with Raphael Luzon on the fate of Libyan Jews

    ‘They think if the Jews come back everything will be ok’

    Scouts Movement in Libya
    Scouts Movement in Libya

    Do a Good Turn Daily

    Bomb squads and the war in Libya
    Bomb squads and the war in Libya

    ‘I won’t stop until the last bomb has been defused’

    An entry from the fifth round of the Libya Uncharted photo award
    Fifth round of the zenith Photo Award Libya Uncharted

    Dust, sweat and sea salt

    Libyans seeking healthcare in Tunisia
    Libyans looking for healthcare in Tunisia

    Care Abroad

    Explore Channel
    zenithTalk Berlin 2
    Building the UAE’s Knowledge Economy

    Building the UAE’s Knowledge Economy

    mona el sayed
    Building Fair Trade Egypt

    Building Fair Trade Egypt

    Amel.jpg
    To Learn from Eachother

    To Learn from Each Other

    Belabbes
    Joining the Debate

    Joining the Debate

    Muhammad.jpg
    Rethinking Education

    Rethinking Education

    Ahmad.jpg
    zenithTalk: Ahmad Al Hidiq

    Tech-Powered Healthcare

    Explore Channel
    Handicraft in and from Lebanon
    Handicraft in and from Lebanon

    Made in Lebanon, again

    Economic Crisis and the Costs of Education in Lebanon
    Economic Crisis and the Costs of Education in Lebanon

    ՙWe Didn’t Want a Temporary Solution՚

    Lebanese Diaspora in France
    Lebanese diaspora in France

    The Port and Paris

    The Future of Karantina
    Beirut after the Blast

    The Future of Karantina

    Why Many Lebanese cannot let go of the Past
    Memory and Politics in Lebanon

    Why Many Lebanese cannot let go of the Past

    Lebanon's Health System in a Critical State
    Hospitals and healthcare in Lebanon

    Lebanon's Health System in a Critical State

    Explore Channel
    All Channels
    • Magazine
    • Photoaward
    • Libya Chronicles
    • zenithTalk
      • Home
      • About
      • Speakers
      • Events
      • Acts
      • Apply
      • Host a talk
    • Lebanon Chronicles
  • Search
Read Time: 9 Minutes
Bookmark this article
Urban Planning in Turkey
The coastal promenade in Istanbul's Salacak districtPhotograph: David Samuel Williams
Urban Planning in Turkey

Istanbul is Yours

Feature
by David Samuel Williams
22.12.2020
Society

Instead of planning new megaprojects, Istanbul’s new administration vows to improve the quality of life and to include its inhabitants in the decision-making process of urban redesign.

“When a man dies, he leaves behind a monument”, the prime minister of Turkey Recep Tayyip Erdoğan announced as he unveiled the Yavuz Sultan Selim Köprüsü (the Third Bosphorus Bridge) in 2018. Indeed, urban planning has always been a trusted instrument in the populist toolbox of authoritarian regimes.

 

There is a long history of autocratic leaders yielding influence over the built urban environment to convey an image of strength, capability, and decisiveness. Crucially, it represents a physical solidification of power forcefully enshrined into the identity of a place to last beyond the rule and lifespan of the respective demagogue.

 

In Turkey, urban planning has gone hand in hand with various other authoritarian strategies to enforce the centralization of power. These include the repression and persecution of public criticism and political opposition, the erosion and weakening of judicial institutions, the instrumentalization of Islamic and nationalist sentiments, and the influence and control over media and news corporations.

 

Urban planning is a particularly popular strategy for neoliberal authoritarian regimes suffering from economic and currency crises, as the construction sector is an effective jobs generator for an abundant and enthusiastic workforce. Hence, in many authoritarian regimes a close relationship between construction magnates and the highest echelons of government can be observed.

 

This relationship has shaped urbanity and facilitated the drive for infrastructural megaprojects in Istanbul. These megaprojects include the aforementioned Yavuz Sultan Selim Köprüsü (one of the world’s longest suspension bridges), as well as Çamlıca Camii (Turkey’s largest mosque with six minarets, opened for prayer in 2019), the new airport (construction began in 2018, estimated to be the world’s largest airport upon completion), and Kanal Istanbul (envisaged as a 43km long and 400m wide canal crossed by six bridges connecting the Black Sea and the Marmara Sea).

 

These megaprojects were devised without consulting local planners or directly affected communities and have been the subject of heavy criticism for their inflated costs and detrimental impacts on the environment.

 

In principle of course, a city the size of Istanbul needs urban planning projects. As the largest metropolis in Europe, Istanbul has undergone a rapid urban transformation fuelled by rural-urban migration and population growth over recent decades, resulting in an intense competition for space. However, the need for appropriate urban planning which reflects and responds to these dynamics has not been met. Istanbul is in the midst of a housing crisis, and the surrounding natural environment is consumed by uncontrolled urban sprawl.

 

When navigating this urban jungle by foot, the lack of pedestrian infrastructure, open public squares or green areas in which citizens can congregate and interact with each other without the need to consume is striking. This is not only illustrative of a neoliberal growth-centric planning paradigm, but also of autocratic governments viewing open space as a potential threat to their authoritarian rule.

 

A common Turkish proverb states that hope won’t be cut from the soul that has not expired. This soul was very much alive in 2019 when the majority of Istanbulites voted for the mayoral candidate Ekrem İmamoğlu of the People’s Republican Party (CHP), as opposed to Binali Yıldırım of Erdoğan’s Justice and Development Party (AKP).

 

Such was the significance of this loss of Turkey’s financial capital and most influential city that election officials, under insistence from the AKP, were pressured into annulling the results and had the elections rerun. Istanbulites responded by voting for İmamoğlu with a considerably larger margin than the first time.

 

In an attempt to deliver on the promise of improving the quality of life and access to public space for the residents of Istanbul, the “İstanbul Senin” (Istanbul is yours) project initiated by the İstanbul Büyükşehir Belediyesi (Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality) and the İstanbul Planlama Ajansı (Istanbul Planning Agency) appears to represent a radically different approach to urban planning.

 

After organising a public urban design competition, three architectural designs from a total of 233 submissions were selected for the remodelling of Salacak, Taksim, and Bakırköy respectively und put to a public vote. Over a period of 4 weeks, over 350,000 Istanbul residents expressed their preference for the submitted architectural designs through an online platform, and the winners were announced at the end of November 2020.

 

The first site selected for remodelling is Salacak, in the municipality of Üsküdar on the Anatolian side of Istanbul. With close-up views of the iconic Kız Kulesi (Maiden’s Tower), this is a popular stretch for visitors from other parts of Istanbul and further afar. Currently, the promenade is flanked by car parking areas making it cumbersome for pedestrians to access a somewhat dilapidated viewing platform.

 

Urban Planning in Turkey
The design for the redesign of the Salacak coastal promenade Istanbul Senin

 

The architectural design chosen by the residents of Istanbul boasts improved public transportation and pedestrian access, as well as recreational green spaces with jogging tracks, playgrounds and an amphitheatre for cultural events. The terraces, apparently inspired by the morphology of the cliffs, offer a venue for visitors to sit and relax. According to the architects, by imitating nature, this viewing platform strengthens the foundation against the threat of erosion from the Bosphorus, protecting the area from coastal flooding.

 

The second site chosen for remodelling is Taksim. Centrally located in the district of Beyoğlu in the heart of Istanbul, the square currently serves as one of the main transportation hubs with access to key bus and metro stations, and in close vicinity to Istiklal Caddesi (Independence Avenue), the main shopping street of Istanbul.

 

Historically, Taksim has been a popular meeting point for staging political rallies, meaning there has always been some police presence on the square. This has increased significantly since the Gezi protests in 2013, after which police barricades and heavily armoured riot vans were set up to prevent any attempts at holding political rallies.

 

Urban Planning in Turkey
The present state of Istanbul's Taksim Square Photograph: David Samuel Williams

 

The architectural design now selected by the residents promises to transform Taksim square into a recreational space for walking and resting. This is to be achieved through the addition of fountains, trees and green areas offering a refuge from the hustle and bustle of the surrounding area. In addition, a new pedestrian bridge with viewing terraces overlooking the Bosphorus will be created which connects Taksim with the nearby Maçka Park.

 

The architectural design specifically refers to implementing adaptable areas which will respond to the changing needs of citizens expressed and voiced through a participatory process organized by a newly formed Taksim Collective.

 

Urban Planning in Turkey
The design for the redesign of Taksim Square Istanbul Senin

 

The third site is in Bakırköy, a predominantly residential middle-class area in western Istanbul in close vicinity to the Marmara Sea. The Bakırköy Cumhuriyet Meydanı (Bakırköy Freedom Square) is a critical transportation intersection, with a highway forming the north-south axis, and a railway forming the east-west axis.

 

Being located at a transportation intersection has resulted in disconnected neighbourhoods. The architectural design chosen is therefore part of a cultural regeneration in an attempt to reconnect these neighbourhoods with wide modern bridges and viewing platforms, as well as promoting cultural spaces and activities.

 

Urban Planning in Turkey
Bakırköy in the west of IstanbulPhotograph: David Samuel Williams

 

By giving its residents a say, the approach taken by the CHP in Istanbul represents merely one of numerous possible measures for a democratization of urban planning. Yet it can still be seen as a noteworthy antidote to the previous top-down approach taken by the AKP with its focus on opulent megaprojects, by shifting toward democratic participation and active citizenship. This could be a first step in encouraging greater social cohesion, increasing institutional legitimacy, and enhancing a communal sense of ownership in a state-society relationship marred by tensions and distrust.

 

There are of course legitimate concerns with this initiative. It is debatable whether the prestigious redesign of public spaces in predominantly middle- and upper-class areas with a hint of overpromise should be the priority in a city in desperate need of safe and affordable housing for underprivileged and marginalized communities, whose involvement in this project is unclear. The process regarding how firms will be awarded tenders has also not been made public yet, and steps need to be taken to make sure that construction is not marred by mismanagement and corruption.

 

Urban Planning in Turkey
Design for the redesign of the Bakırköy transportation hub Istanbul Senin

 

Furthermore, there is the concern that the redevelopment of squares with such socio-historic significance such as Taksim reduces the essential symbolism for political opinion-forming and engagement. And finally, there is also little information available on the use of climate-friendly building materials, or adherence to any other sustainability criteria for that matter.

 

In addition, İmamoğlu will have to contend with a national government intent on making the CHP look incompetent and inefficient. Since the local elections of 2019, the suppression of opposition-led municipalities can be added to the list of authoritarian strategies employed by the Turkish government. This is manifested through the withholding of funds, the exclusion of local officials from decision-making and policy-planning processes, and public agitation.

 

Currently, contracts are being formalized along with the finalization of application blueprints and legal procedures for the chosen architectural designs. Only time will tell whether and how the AKP may try to influence the process. Meanwhile, the newest vote for a further remodelling site of the harbour area in Kadiköy has already been opened to the public.


David Samuel Williams is 2020/21 Mercator-IPC Fellow at Istanbul Policy Center, Sabancı University.

By: 
David Samuel Williams
Turkey
Istanbul
Infrastructure
Development
Whatsapp

Related Articles

Interview with Nicholas Danforth
CHP Chairman Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu and Erdoğan's former foreign minister and prime minister, Future Party Chairman Ahmet Davutoğlu at a meeting in January 2021.

‘Erdoğan’s approach guarantees maximum backlash’

by Marc Imperatori
French Syria expert Fabrice Balance on IS, the Kurds and Turkey
French Syria expert Fabrice Balance on IS, the Kurds and Turkey

»A new generation of militants«

by Raphael Bossniak
Interview with Galip Dalay on EU-Turkey relations
Interview with Galip Dalay on EU-Turkey relations

‘What kind of Turkey does the EU want to engage with?’

by Robert Chatterjee
Beirut after the Blast
The Future of Karantina

The Future of Karantina

by Angela Brussel

  • Home
  • Channels
  • About zenith
  • Reporting Grant
  • Culture
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Innovation
  • Travel
  • Society
  • Vacancies
  • Contact Us

   

Sehr geehrtes Club-Mitglied, wir arbeiten derzeit an einem neuen zenith-Shop. Bis es soweit ist, können Sie ihr Nutzerprofil leider nicht direkt bearbeiten. Bitte senden Sie eine Email an shop@zenith.me und wir nehmen die gewünschte Änderung gerne für Sie vor.

© 2022 CANDID Foundation gGmbH

  • Imprint
  • Netiquette
  • Vacancies
  • Terms and conditions

Developed by UTEEK

Liebe Kundin, lieber Kunde, aus technischen Gründen sind Bestellungen über den zenith-Shop im Moment nicht möglich. Wenn Sie ein Einzelheft auf Rechnung kaufen wollen, etwa die aktuelle Ausgabe, senden Sie bitte eine Email mit Name und Adresse an shop@zenith.me und unser Kundenservice wird sich bei Ihnen melden.

Verstanden